
Repair or Buy a Shed? Pros and Cons
Guides · May 28, 2024 · By the Beau-frère à louer team
It's often the first question we ask ourselves when major repairs are needed or when our shed is no longer the pride of the neighbourhood it once was.
At first, buying a new garden shed can be very costly, but the challenges and concerns that come with repairing an existing shed can sometimes justify a complete replacement. Of course, cost is not the only thing to consider. Let's look together at the advantages and disadvantages of both options.
3 Reasons to Choose to Repair Your Shed
1. Repairing a shed is often less costly than buying.
New quality sheds can be very expensive.
A new garden shed can cost up to $10,000 or more, not including materials to prepare its foundation, the land, and the labour needed for installation. Repairing an old garden shed, on the other hand, is often a less costly alternative—even if major repairs are needed, you can usually save more than half the value of a new shed.
2. Refurbishing your shed is faster than buying a new one.
Many people think it's faster to buy a new shed than to repair it. The case is often the opposite.
In fact, there are a number of reasons why repairing a shed is a faster option than buying.
To start, you need to plan the removal of your current shed and the hauling of waste to transport to a landfill. Plus, that can take weeks or even months to find, buy, and have your new shed delivered. Then, once the new shed is purchased, you still need to assemble or have it installed. Finally, if the shed is a different size, you'll need to plan time for site preparation and setting up a new foundation for the newcomer. For all these reasons, repairing a shed can often be the fastest and most efficient option.
3. Repairing your shed is more environmentally friendly than buying.
Why is it more environmentally friendly to repair your shed?
The answer is simple: environmental waste recovery. Not only do you reduce the amount of waste sent to landfills like asphalt shingle roofing, wood, and vinyl, but you also contribute to resource conservation. Every time you restore a shed, you extend its lifespan and prevent it from becoming waste. And that's beneficial for the environment. So, when you maintain your shed, think of the environment and decide to repair it rather than replace it.
The Brother-in-Law Club
Maintenance - Renovation - Maintenance Plan
Become a member for free*
- Free Subscription
- Save $10/hour on handyman service*
- Priority on Requests
- Free annual preventative inspection
*With prepayment of $65/month in service, applicable to all our banners
3 Reasons to Prefer Buying Rather Than Repairing.
1. The size and features of your current shed no longer suit you.
If your needs have changed and you now need more storage space, for example, it may be better to buy a shed that better meets your needs rather than invest time and money in modifications on top of necessary repairs. Many prefabricated garden shelter manufacturers offer a wide range of options you can customise.
2. No Surprises
When you buy a new garden shed, the process seems straightforward enough. You choose the size and style you want that matches well with your home, then you pay for it and have it delivered to you. Be careful, it's not that simple.
There are a few things you need to keep in mind when buying a new garden shed to avoid surprises.
First, make sure to check the dimensions of the shed before buying it. It's not uncommon for people to misjudge the size of their yard and end up with a shed that's too large or too small for the new yard layout. Second, take a look at the new accessories available for sheds these days. You can get everything from skylights to solar panels, so it's worth doing some research to get all the information on what's available. And finally, take inventory of everything you'd like to store in addition to what's currently there.
3. Your shed is no longer salvageable.
There comes a time when deciding to buy a new shed is the only logical solution. There are a few things to consider to make the right choice.
If, as they say, rot is widespread, your roof leaks, your floor is rotten, you have problems with your doors and windows, your foundation is no longer level, or your siding is damaged, it may be more profitable in the long run to buy.
And if you want to repair, but you're not handy?
So you've decided that repairing your shed is the best solution for you, but you don't have the time, tools, know-how, or skills to do it.
To get around all that, it's easy—you need to count on a specialised company with a good reputation and… let them do all the work for you. Fortunately, I know one for you!
Beau-frère à louer, ever heard of it?
There are others out there, but Beau-frère à louer is one of your choices to consider. In business since 2009, we have brothers-in-law in several locations across the Greater Montréal area and suburbs, and we offer the best service and warranty for your work.
We have an expert in your neighbourhood:
North Shore of Montréal, Laval, Montréal, Lanaudière, South Shore of Montréal, we regularly add expert brothers-in-law for sheds and soon everywhere in Quebec.
Our customers can count on our customer service and discuss their project and request a quote. You can also book a phone appointment directly online at a time that works best for you.
We also offer handyman services for all the small jobs needed to maintain your home or condo.
https://beau-frerealouer.com/services/reparation-cabanon-remise/
2293 Île-des-Lys, Terrebonne, Québec J6Y 6A2.
Tel. 514-666-2328 ext. 101
Email: info@beau-frerealouer.com
Read also

The Best Trade in 2024: Handyman Work
Read the article →Law 16 Maintenance Log for Condominiums: Complete Guide for Condo Boards
Read the article →Got a project in mind after reading?
First step — the easy one: check if we have a brother-in-law available in your area.
or go straight to your free quote
(514) 666-2328